CK Retro Review: Together Through Life by Bob Dylan

When it arrived in 2009, Bob Dylan’s Together Through Life was met with almost universal praise from reviewers (yours truly included, I must admit.) And yet…. The album, which features Dylan co-writing with Robert Hunter and getting instrumental support from Heartbreaker Mike Campbell and accordionist David Hidalgo, hasn’t blossomed with the passing of time like other late-period Dylan albums tend to do. I would wager that it’s not too high on any Bob fanatic’s playlist these days, burdened by a few too many generic blues tracks and a dearth of thunderbolt moments. Here is a song-by-song review.


10. “Jolene”- This song is as generic as it gets both lyrically and musically. Even Bob’s crack band fails to provide it a jolt, leaving it at bar-band material at best. I’ll take Dolly Parton’s “Jolene” over this one any day of the week.

9. “My Wife’s Home Town”- Maybe Dylan and Hunter made each other chuckle with the lyrics here, but for the listener, well, I guess you had to be there. Dylan’s vocals are uncomfortably serrated on the track and the pace is sludgy. Take the semi-funny punch line of the refrain away, and even that loses its luster after its repeated a few times, and there’s not much left here.

8. “Shake Shake Mama”- This one has an effective enough groove, but the repetitiveness of it begs for lyrics to provide some spice and variety. Alas, there is little life in them besides some worn over blues cliches which are hung together without any regard for how they fit into the song.


7. “If You Ever Go To Houston”- This exercise in Tex-Mex balladry is understated enough to be charming. Dylan sets the song in an Old West full of gunslingers and barrooms, but you can tell all that the second Hidalgo’s accordion strolls across the dusty trail. Nothing too fancy, but welcome nonetheless.

6. “Life Is Hard”- Melodies are usually not what one discusses when dealing with Dylan’s later work, but “Life Is Hard” has a subtly affecting tune. Even if Bob can’t quite grab the higher notes, the strain is emblematic of his character’s woeful plight. This dude is seriously messed up over the departure of his love, so much so that he feels a “chilly breeze/In place of memories.” He can’t even muster up some trademark Dylanesque black humor to leaven his plight. As a result, the song teeters on the edge of being too maudlin, but Dylan’s vocal keeps on the right side of the line.

5. “I Feel A Change Comin’ On”- This song has the feel of one of The Band’s more soulful tracks, which means Hidalgo plays the Garth Hudson role here and plays it well. When the album came out, everybody jumped on the lines about Billie Joe Shaver and James Joyce as emblematic of Dylan’s unique songwriting perspective. For me, I prefer the other bridge, where Bob opines about the futility of dreams in simple but stinging words. There’s a good vibe to this one on the whole, even if it’s not quite the definitive statement it aspires to be.

4. “It’s All Good”- Maybe this one should have had a subtitle for the sake of accuracy: “It’s All Good (But Not Really)”. Dylan seems to be saying that the title phrase is not only wrong-headed but dangerous. His narrator has his eyes wide open about the world’s ills, but he’s also ready to take advantage of the chaos where he can. Even if the lyrics are a bit too obvious, the song gets by on the maniacal joy that Dylan seems to be having throughout.

3. “Beyond Here Lies Nothing”- The dynamic music pushes this one a long way, with the accordion hook and Campbell’s powerful licks playing off each other and the flamenco rhythm nicely. The lyrics may not be the most evocative set in Bob’s career (although “boulevards of broken cars” is quite a potent phrase), but the words fit the meter tight to make it prime sing-along material. Basically, it’s an airtight single, and that’s no easy feat.

2. “Forgetful Heart”- A suitably moody recording with lyrics just suggestive enough to make this sound maybe more profound that it is. Dylan has had conversations with his ticker before (“Heart Of Mine”), but none so ominous as this. That last couplet is a doozy (“The door has closed forevermore/If indeed there ever was a door”) and the song sustains its central conceit well all the way through. It’s more of a triumph of songwriting technique than an example of inspired profundity, but it’s still fine.


1. “This Dream Of You”- While it’s probably not fair to cast aspersions on the contributions of Robert Hunter based on the fact that the lone song which Dylan wrote alone is by far the best on the album, it is probably fair to say that it’s not a coincidence. Like other songs on the album, Dylan doesn’t try to fling his lyrics too far afield of the music, which in this case is a lovely South-of-the-border tune with fiddles and accordion in perfect conjunction. Yet this is the one Together Through Life song that has a little of the old Dylan mystery and magic. What seems on the surface like a simple broken-hearted lament actually goes much deeper and darker than that, until the very existence of the narrator’s dream girl comes into question. It’s haunting stuff, and it’s miles and away the best song here.

(E-mail me at or follow me on Twitter @JimBeviglia. For a more in-depth look at the songs of Bob Dylan, check out the link below to my book Counting Down Bob Dylan: His 100 Finest Songs, available now at all major online booksellers.)


10 Comments on “CK Retro Review: Together Through Life by Bob Dylan”

  1. markrb1 says:

    Think maybe I need to go back and revisit “This Dream of You”. Indeed one of the great aspects of this series of posts is going back and listening to tracks I’ve previously overlooked with another guys perspective in mind. Kind of hoping that if you do treat us to a review on Friday its “Tempest” and you decide to leave “Christmas in the Heart” for a festive special. I’m quite keen to know if you love “Tempest” as much as I do. Although I wouldn’t bet on us having the same favourite track.

  2. hans altena says:

    This Dream of You is the only song which seems not be written just to amuse, like the others. It was a fun album, and as it goes with fun, it doesn’t last, uou’re completely right and even a bit generous in you values, though maybe the songs deserve it, cause they served their purpose, even be it for just a while. I find it bores me and I wished he had waited till Tempest and put This Dream on that one, it would have served as a moment of mercy together with Roll on John, now it is snowed under by the mediocrity of the rest…

  3. Bob says:

    ‘This Dream of You’ is, I think, yet another of those understated, minor masterpieces that populate Dylan’s albums (‘Sign on the Window’ comes to mind, for example, or ‘Never Say Goodbye’): a quiet desperation, a kind of cracked poignancy in a world-wearied voice lends a perfect edge to chiselled lyrics that don’t waste a word – and the last verse in performance shakes the soul…

  4. Jim,

    You haven’t actually named ‘This Dream Of You’ in your text!

    It’s interesting that live performances of ‘Forgetful Heart’ are particularly dramatic and powerful. (At least the performances gleaned from Youtube.) Tempo slowed down and emphasis on Donnie Herron’s violin – rather wish it had been done that way on the album.

    Thanks for your postings – I look forward to agreeing and disagreeing with each one!

  5. Shelley says:

    I never listen to this album, but knowing it was coming up on the Countdown I put it on … and yep, it’s just kinda bland and predictable. Weren’t the songs originally written for a film, but the film never materialized so Dylan decided to records the songs anyway? Perhaps these songs work better as a soundtrack. Or am I remembering incorrectly?

    • countdownkid says:

      I think that “Life Is Hard” was written for a movie, but I don’t know about the rest. But it’s an interesting thought. I’d like to see that movie.

      • hans altena says:

        He recorded Life is Hard for the movie (can’t remember which one), and then this caused such fun that he decided to write the rest down and played it in a few days with the same band, so it was out of enjoyment, and you could feel that, but it did not prevent the feeling of shallowness that crept up on you, except with the emotionally deep cutting This Dream of You… I heard it a year after I lost my first woman because of a mistake in the hospital, and the sense you have of a presence that at the same time is not in normal reality there, is expressed i such an evoking way that indeed my soul gets shaken, like now at this moment when I read those words and am remembered…

  6. steve says:

    was I the only person to feel disappointed with this album ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s