CK Retro Review: The Ghost Of Tom Joad by Bruce Springsteen

After briefly reuniting with the E Street Band for a Greatest Hits project, Bruce Springsteen once again pulled back from the grandeur and hugeness of his rock-based music for an intimate batch of story songs. Like Nebraska, 1995’s The Ghost Of Tom Joad had its basis in folk music, although Springsteen allowed the stray electric instrument now and then on this album even as he kept things stark. He also brought the social issues which lurked in the nooks and crannies of the Nebraska songs more to the forefront on this album, without, for the most part, making it all taste like medicine. Here is a song-by-song review.

TWO STARS

12. “The New Timer”- This one drags. All of the depressing themes become pretty burdensome, especially without any melody to provide a little light.

11. “Balboa Park”- The way that the tale of the protagonist Spider ends without any ceremony in a sudden, violent flash shows how much Springsteen had changed from the romanticized street drama of the old days. Still, there’s not much of a character arc for this poor young kid caught up in drug smuggling, but maybe that’s the point.

THREE STARS

10. “Dry Lightning”- The lyrics get a bit disheveled as the song goes on, but there’s still a fascinating inner monologue at play here. There’s something so ineffectual about the titular phenomenon that it’s a perfect metaphor here. It reflects the futile efforts of this wayward soul to find some sort of comfort.

9. “Galveston Bay”- Springsteen subverts expectations by having the two protagonists here, who seem destined for some sort of deciding confrontation, pass each other in the night, better judgment winning out over societal pressures for once. The impact of the tale is limited somewhat by the fact that this sounds too much like a short story set (barely) to music.

8. “Youngstown”- It’s along the same lines as Billy Joel’s “Allentown,” albeit not quite as catchy. The full-band approach really helps here, because Springsteen makes his points about a dying industrial town in fashion that is more workmanlike than transcendent, which I suppose is apropos for the subject matter. The ominous moan of Soosie Tyrell’s violin playing off the twang of Marty Rifkin’s pedal steel really helps to elevate what could have been forgettable material.

7. “My Best Was Never Good Enough”- I know that it’s little more than a throwaway, but it does provide some badly-needed, irreverent humor at the end of what up until then is an unrelentingly bleak set of subjects. And it takes a crack at Forrest Gump, which, for a Pulp Fiction backer like me, wins it a few points.

6. “Highway 25”- The story is right out of some B-movie: Lust leads to crime leads to death. But Springsteen underplays the lurid nature of it all to get at the psychology that would make someone act so recklessly. “I told myself it was all something in her/But as we drove I knew it was something in me,” is the narrator’s self-aware summation. The climax, with its flashing imagery, is reminiscent of the closing scenes of Neil Young’s “Powderfinger.”

5. “Sinaloa Cowboys”- This is one of many songs on the album where it’s impossible to listen without a sense of creeping dread. You just know it isn’t going to end well, even as Springsteen’s melody matches the tenderness of the relationship between the two young brothers. The final twist, with one brother burying the other in the hiding place for their money stash after the meth shack which provided that stash explodes, feels more inevitable than ironic, which is why it stings all the more.

FOUR STARS

4. “Straight Time”- A simmering slow-burner that hasn’t received enough attention outside of Springsteen diehards, this track is another that benefits from the full band behind Springsteen. Even as they restrain themselves from any type of showy playing, they create the stifling atmosphere that the song requires. What better way to accompany the tale of a man whose release from jail transported him to a different kind of prison, one in which his urge toward mayhem and chaos is squelched by a steady job and family life. “Seems you can’t get any more than half-free,” Springsteen sings in one of several striking lines that lay bare the character’s insides. We leave him with befouled hands, dreams of escape, and a newly sawed-off gun in the basement, and we carry with us a portrait much more insightful than the old clichéd view of the recidivist criminal.

3. “Across The Border”- What does it say about the overall mood of The Ghost Of Tom Joad that the most hopeful song on the record is one in which the narrator is probably beckoning his love to join him from the Great Beyond? That appears to be the figurative “border” at play in this lovely track which boasts the album’s most ingratiating melody and a wonderful turn from Soosie Tyrell with a harmonized violin part. “For what are we without hope in our hearts?” our narrator asks, which is a stunning question for Springsteen to put in his mouth considering the laundry list of tragedies and social ills the album documents. That’s typical Bruce though: Forcing us to believe in something even when all evidence points us the opposite way. When the music is this moving, it’s easy to be swayed.

FIVE STARS

2. “The Ghost Of Tom Joad”- Springsteen has taken this song in more of a bombastic direction of late, but I’ll take the desolation of the original every time. His voice barely above a whisper, Springsteen catalogues the degrading interconnectedness of poverty, hunger, and homelessness in language that doesn’t pull punches. Notice how the melody rises with a sliver of hope when he sings, “The highway is alive tonight,” only to crash back down to reality with “But nobody’s kiddin’ nobody about where it goes.” The only remedy is to call back Steinbeck’s unforgettable anti-hero from The Grapes Of Wrath to repeat his credo and banish all this nonsense to another dimension. If only it were that easy.

1. “The Line”- If we’re going to compare The Ghost Of Tom Joad to Nebraska, “The Line” would have to be its “Highway Patrolman,” the emotional centerpiece where there are no easy answers or choices and circumstances mock all simplistic notions of right and wrong. There’s even a standoff in the headlights in this song as well. And again, even in this long story song, Springsteen’s ability to cut to the heart of the matter shines through; you can sum up all of the underlying problems in the words of grizzled Border Patrol agent Bobby Ramirez: “Carl, hunger is a powerful thing.” This song, more than any other on the album, strikes just the right balance between telling a compelling little story and eloquently highlighting the big-picture issue. In this case, the issue was immigration, which shows that Springsteen was prescient with this one as well.

(E-mail me at countdownkid@hotmail.com and follow me on Twitter @JimBeviglia. My new book, Counting Down Bruce Springsteen, arrives in June, but pre-orders are now available at all major online booksellers.)

http://www.amazon.com/Counting-Down-Bruce-Springsteen-Finest/dp/1442230657

http://www.amazon.com/Counting-Down-Bob-Dylan-Finest/dp/0810888238

Advertisements

8 Comments on “CK Retro Review: The Ghost Of Tom Joad by Bruce Springsteen”

  1. Hans altena says:

    Have to say This time I strongly disagree, but how could it be anything else? Nebraska and The Ghost of Tom Joad are for me the masterpieces that win my sympathy for Springsteen, where for the rest I just have to respect his genius. And all those 2 an 3 ratings baffle me, for instance the song My Best etc floors me, and I could go on that way. But okay, this album is so great an exception in his oeuvre that I can understand your point of view, even Nebraska is nearer to the rest than this quiet jewel, which maybe coul have been served with a bit more clearness in the production and the singing, but the writing really rules.

    • countdownkid says:

      I agree that the writing rules, but it’s not a lyric sheet competition. Nebraska’s melodies and arrangements are almost universally more vibrant and potent than the ones on Ghost, and that makes a big difference. I have no problem with quiet songs, but I have a problem with dull ones, which, on the songs that I ranked lower, is what it comes down to, for me anyway.

  2. Ralf Sauter says:

    “The impact of the tale is limited somewhat by the fact that this sounds too much like a short story set (barely) to music” – I would say the whole album is like a collection of short stories in the vein of for example Cormac McCarthy. I think Springsteen is the most interesting when he kinda steers away from his usual thing and this is a great example – the California setting alone makes this one captivating. He lived in there at the time and used to ride his motorcycle around meeting people at the border who were sometimes involved with the whole drug and hustling thing; I believe Sinaloa Cowboys is based on a story he was told by one of those people, a Mexican guy. The Line is one of his masterpieces IMO, always devastates me. The songwriting really is great, a proper testament of his skill with the pen and paper – just like Nebraska, and Devils & Dust. I wish he’d make one more folk album.

    • hans altena says:

      The Cormac McCarthy reference is quite interesting, although luckily his idiosyncratic style, which I as a European very much admire, isn’t imitated… it is more about the feeling it exudes… and yes, the music is a bit too simple here and there, but it serves the tale telling and bleak atmosphere perfectly…

    • countdownkid says:

      The pen and the paper definitely do the trick, but what about the instruments and the vocals? One area where Dylan’s folk music, with the exception of the unassailable Nebraska, outdoes Springsteen’s is just in the vibrancy and the inventiveness of the performances, even when it’s just acoustic guitar and vocal. Dylan always projected oodles of personality in those songs and a wide range of emotions, whereas Springsteen tends to flatline (sometimes) and relies on the words to carry all the weight. Understand that I think The Ghost Of Tom Joad is a great album, but it’s one that doesn’t always demand the attention, with the music and the performances, that those lyrics deserve.

  3. Baggy says:

    Sorry guys, worthy but dull. Bruce can adopt a style, but he doesn’t have Dylan’s variety of phrasing, and sheer unpredictability of delivery, to make 10plus songs interesting. I have a cd single, good but that is enough.

    I realise i’m off message and it is a classic, so I’ll shut up now til we get to Outlaw Pete.

  4. Ralf Sauter says:

    Devils & Dust and Nebraska are certainly more interesting musically…

  5. […] Other Opinions Are Available. What did these people have to say about The Ghost of Tom Joad? Rolling Stone Sputnik Music Countdown Kid […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s